The Richman Group of Florida, Inc. v. Pinellas County, Florida
SocialSecurity DueProcess
Unequal treatment of similarly situated persons under Florida's equal protection analysis
QUESTION PRESENTED The Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment requires the state to demonstrate a rational basis for treating similarly situated persons differently. Florida has applied a unique equal protection analysis testing whether the state has a rational basis for making its ultimate legislative decision — without considering the difference in treatment afforded a plaintiff as compared to others similarly situated. The question presented is: Does Florida’s failure to consider the “difference in treatment” between a plaintiff and its similarly situated comparators conflict with this Court’s wellworn standard applicable to equal protection claims? (i)