Whether the Pennsylvania Dunham Rule, which excludes natural gas from the definition of 'minerals' for purposes of mineral rights ownership, violates the Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment by depriving mineral rights owners of just compensation for the taking of their property rights in the natural gas deposits beneath their land

QUESTION(S) PRESENTED | —illiem (4, Uschock content; Loh = . Pye LDunhan ale /, Peonsgleas/s we bioh #2 feos; LE Furs! bes is bof conshthevng’ | 2 mineral Fy Peon ry lems “ali fre abl Ot4ep tte Fog in The Ufsf The Dunkin Bh, lf viel» tos Fhe | Lik th a4/ Soarleen fk "end wank or Mae process JUST con pensoftrn. The ne he tn A he Sites Power and we ary tepriveliay 4y Mops / Lag ¢ wpa 24d vot % ; | -— er “Cas. FT, Pon downens en Aon shake as depriving ot fost compensa Pion Poyat, j fies Z) yo ee “ . i; f phe Miebachs Never Clingu ished Shep hae Ys ch oefe ° ; mene rk SOWA PiGh ty J, Sh ° che, o he arishe le gar yah y is Ol et The Lip Danks hy be “hing thee NIUGA f5 ‘ FS iy pg, AA sha .