Jesse Lloyd Hall v. Daniel Paramo, Warden
DueProcess HabeasCorpus
Whether federal courts must take the allegations of a state writ petition as true when weighing if the state's denial was objectively unreasonable
QUESTION(S) PRESENTED A. IF THE STANDARD UNDER BAREFOOT V. ESTELLE, 463 U.S. 893 (1983) FOR PRELIMINARY REVIEW OF A STATE WRIT PETITION REQUIRES THE ALLEGATIONS OF THE PETITION “TO BE TAKEN AS TRUE'IS IT NOT ENCUMBANT ON FEDERAL: COURTS TO DO SO AS WELL IN WEIGHING. WHETHER THE STATE'S “DENIAL WAS “OBJECTIVELY UNREASONABLE?" [28 U.S.C. : 2254] A ; -B. IS IT RECANTATLON WHEN A FIFTEEN YEAR OLD ALLEGED VICTIM REPORTS TO THE POSECUTOR POLICE MISCONDUCT, SUBORNATION OF PERJURY, WITNESS INTIMIDATION AND OTHER CRIMES RESULTING IN A COERCED AND FABRICATED , VICTIM STATEMENT PRIOR TO HER TESTIFYING? ¢. -IS A-FIFTEEN YEAR OLD FEMALE ALLEGED -VICTIM DENYING SHE IS A VICTIM OF A GRIME AND. ANY INAPPROPRIATE MISCONDCUT ENTITLED TO MORE SOCIETAL PROTECTION. THAN THE SIXTEEN. AND FIFTEEN YEAR OLD MURDER ' SUSPECTS IN TAYLOR V. MADDOX, 366 F.3d 992 (9TH CIR. 2003) AND HALEY V. OHIO, 322 0-5. 596, 599-601 (1948) TO PREVENT DETECTIVE FROM CGERCING A FALSE STATEMENT FROM HER? iL