No. 18-7401

Robert Shapiro v. United States

Lower Court: Seventh Circuit
Docketed: 2019-01-15
Status: Denied
Type: IFP
Response WaivedIFP
Tags: civil-procedure civil-rights commerce-clause due-process federalism free-speech general-welfare standing takings taxation
Latest Conference: 2019-03-15
Question Presented (AI Summary)

Whether Congress has the power to levy and collect taxes, imposts, and excises to pay the debts and provide for the common defense and general welfare of the United States, but that such taxes, imposts, and excises must be uniform throughout the United States

Question Presented (OCR Extract)

QUESTION(S) PRESENTED (‘ous Congress shall have Qwer to ley aud oollect | —Tades | (yes , Lmpests aud Excises, 4 pay fue pps ond prot he Loy tee common Peolence ou wellare of fre | — Uulled Hates: but all Dties , Impes!s and Ey cises Sha ll te unifor™ thoughout the United Slales? Veter ea : ; | N 7 | : QUESTION(S) PRESENTED | Qirprn a-ak wias on owat (owt case atonen mat D&tret doclokMocleek | Was oped by tee plaiatift oo on gn far original purposes avigin was on ox} by roadan cycler Service. for Customor service. daveact ov ack authority veac} +o pr se ak Previous cose fram Similary CONSEAULNCES CMSGUC LES Come \oy Vd Colendomts. or ani lent Bes fovees owe at at dacler ot Bocleck sev viinize Purpese , Yelling, ov Foy Hospitality aspect ov Washichy Toy clo w22rerMe moomor Dishict an on a he CuSlawSevulee fp oe Veackin was reported report choractor, On 6 ACU% Report foresdt mmainwale inthe past Plead Pleadling Syshew Meidbuct | by es ridlonls problde cause Cause of et allege for or Hhat The complae YLO PMS Severe Cause av evimae was Carded wnaluvely by Oslo he complaint pur pose for hearing jo Olam ov construe gros groBS Ty causes ak ak Cantnefhad fu Compl Seppe) AF the preulays Case ak te previas haovivg Neng wis rondon voudan omnipotent Causes, aviginal Puy pokes ar Lorgness Lonress fraetge of tse andl se Fuodledlye was ator evpecled Dy aa asc oe 04 ator lay by ccmelavnt by complet fer dred h, \ yas at af was at wcidlk ov Compelivg records recrd por on Okscr Vox Chovacla-Chavackir was af Conmerak ae Justlutin -dasovlee challonges eLleck achionment, i dian achieuemonts ov » yosolue (05S , Dendlredal velvel oO” For ovidace (he Quarts or hoshlAy | \ Alwakonat at chovaclerize the ola t£0 Rebrard $ idler ras oullowrsh ar WAD ato wns Childish or ne 28 andor wide and ywdeness ov CYroydShapivd, AS a faupus Cvlolorty , trovblemaleor-or UO lend mM Yetig Tous eStablishuont act of terra, Or taht loy derresfre Anveats on onat Rolo Shapo olosovves nore Liduc{lp (iled) Shales, His histo or report roavess report olscyiloe {oy Psbe Seo Only need 4 gyadlode ohon Poor} Was Pressured) | 4 chook, plaig IavIZ2 or Yeromg. ChovacdeOct nolpedted wipromch | Ute pecledrass or oct memerat Te lists Polar put on Mfemnbaton, $s succeed aud) value ices for Obiwiing Vist of dalondauls Prolessisna | approval obtain license, Oreit ond Om PLOYmoret employer} fry Salovy on on Débpert Was Woh Ogae5s eM Clovical ality, or Cluvical infermahin LapSeve Yolore vial, Mowing Poort Wale Cxomples with help of \elp sek lt ach*bion, oul (ea QSSoctud™ | lick by Dest duonce Sek daonce crt apply Wr lex] leve| of asSecred fue Fdvg, wuciay | backing In Better Jeamwov'k ov aie £ J | N Mat was place ame Wy place amdrina cif preving acl of ow woanngly| Be hlowadel a ; epi setinn | ondihlemoc or power oblam con moncii isiithy why hs ea i) doctor toy at onatat cine or wns for forgive place, hecdle , or pronechor i of va or (wel pt ne origin wean haat Por wrife ov lifevecte | ae [yal dilbre ot Conferiniy tran fe holiorn appear ov oli appean belere Fron pursuit oy shavacke fe ad cli ose aly of ch tan ov gerealed aglace,+ime, ev act such such was S/o SO | Toled Jenouedoe Leon Som agility was ololami bnoedge ond tase Case p/omiSes did dheashes was by py Moke Saver mastery mastery or ove dict OHics| jo pica jor Yorba was crafps in study, omplele o exer CH Se. oraftstudy Ly poten +r . oredl, 4, Cais Loa larnce oa ow Place \oy THe ox Tes Woe iMprovisect or oer wel de Slow Shows al en \ balances, Vega litigator, 7 velel act acls gam Aochorate place jor Go's \ouels of shows Vesulor sailing aster Tunchin accel maton +o | tigation ude imdrr fron yoaR diese, Maskws, Power bya office or bya deposition Deposition at al Decline | ame ownership agreement unconsciously commoraled toast at pallet Woh (om yielded Own! polew” (ow bo angry ously provdlee, huoke , or Implamonct brolledige fom orbit rela} arbi LPeld veloc] ar law a lien eloelor Veloel unconse Ieusly srr | Piclds ov aver lop pass , yest

Docket Entries

2019-03-18
Petition DENIED.
2019-02-21
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 3/15/2019.
2019-02-14
Waiver of right of respondent United States to respond filed.
2019-01-15
Petition for a writ of certiorari and motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis filed. (Response due February 14, 2019)

Attorneys

Robert Shapiro
Robert Shapiro — Petitioner
Robert Shapiro — Petitioner
United States
Noel J. FranciscoSolicitor General, Respondent
Noel J. FranciscoSolicitor General, Respondent