Did the lower courts violate the constitutional rights of an Iraq War Veteran (Petitioner) by allowing the Respondent to utilize the same falsified evidence that was previously used to impede an investigation conducted by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs?

QUESTION(S) PRESENTED Did the lower courts violate the constitutional rights of an Iraq War Veteran (Petitioner) by allowing the Respondent to utilize the same falsified evidence that was previously used to impede an investigation conducted by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs? Did the lower courts ignore binding precedent by ruling in ; favor of a litigant that engaged in Spoliation of Evidence?