Did the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals make the right decision in dismissing Plaintiff Thomas' appeal and affirming the dismissal of the District Court regarding Plaintiff Thomas' First Amendment Retaliation Claim against Leann Walker-Williams?

QUESTION(S) PRESENTED (1) Did the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals make the right decision in dismissing Plaintiff Thomas’ appeal and affirming the dismissal of the District Court regarding Plaintiff Thomas’ First Amendment Retaliation Claim against Leann WalkerWilliams? (2) Did Defendant Leann Walker-Williams attach evidence to support her Motion for Summary Judgment she filed in the District Court to satisfy her burden under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 56(c)? (3) Was it appropriate for the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals to affirm the District Court’s disposition in dismissing Plaintiff Thomas’ First Amendment Claim for Retaliation : against Leann Walker-Williams when the only evidence Walker-Williams used was an Affidavit, and Plaintiff Thomas replied in his Reply Brief (Doc. #68, filed 6-28-18) with an Affidavit of his own arguing the facts alleged by Defendant Leann WalkerWilliams? ii