No. 19-7169

Daniel Eric Cobble v. United States

Lower Court: Eleventh Circuit
Docketed: 2020-01-06
Status: Denied
Type: IFP
Response WaivedRelisted (2)IFP
Tags: civil-procedure civil-rights commercial-value due-process fifth-amendment just-compensation patent physical-appropriation public-use standing takings takings-clause
Latest Conference: 2020-05-21 (distributed 2 times)
Question Presented (AI Summary)

Whether the Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment requires the government to pay just compensation when it physically appropriates private property for public use, even if the property has no commercial value or the owner has no plans to develop it?

Question Presented (OCR Extract)

No question identified. : peer proupuyeddo g 9 MOE py aifsrab i DO | Sid wv! aprre 7ymn® lre psu ohn _ wiseye/oye yard 2 61g S)S-/ fo Wey ‘Dw ope aaa YF WYKPY P22 Sy x vi PENI XE ET ALE hypwo gd s (Sheree re ils of ye faves have Fn Bee wt San Bo vaya epeyfP ‘Saafrafle Garres “Yyels ld. Apps Gore vy et SeS PZ wel LPG 2 sya » Ys frau vyMeoD vE P vip A9 Sb af Ae 4/2 yt// ae ne a PS xr lys byw? (4 PPUNAP JIM pies S)eedle <y yrnr4!'> 4) ) eh Bakr iprw wy wae ves GILNASaud (S)NOILSENO Wb openers BIA weet bey ere IS eed <P Seay ae ed emgo mys Lasddy gyn! is ; ZU Ly ie eae Tote wig fina x$2 6d} Bjmoges EZ ane p> amay ry Keefe PE +h sien pasate Gob)? vt Os make Basson Bape pon VND ys ite ftw Ctyjad Sypipytutos $100 Ber “OA sos neu Ufay “of ave av seh 29 “he Suey py © e\prta Ses sYoga pgeow an para SB wet AV We PON $7 hor Sapo Say )aey Ze Toth ees Sa ene yee . wee Leven fue 42 SIO Y C } & epexap x 'e> Wf ute 2. a PIR? ie ; YrD Ped LD ko YF hy $2 yne Sof pape fe Spreng Kat {2 0% ov veostes ppb lpr Jay Yer YM fivg 43 usu lobo Desa 2 poor Vf | | SHA AYSOICD Z A Poe ee ES S20d PY'PFD Me” Ie t-8 0 defsgearyP TBD SE, ~ I~ fas-sgh sonar) 3 Welt 4a oe ppp daliigyo dep, “a5 go er _Lvlaayllo al slay rt ea | FID wp Sv! Jepps Yaner » 49 ARwE! Sean [po ys ramen 2 Srsbof? soles henge pee “iNy edd» Sf ws Yyedlr+s pf, winged oF es os Si aA | 2°8SP CBS) s/0g pote Iiyt> yeas ra prob Ljy 8 pG2r2~WveYp wa ep} alg Sapo ef Aotf fv ne payed PY Yond we Yes Wnt. kat pl Suay SYA MAA AVP uly IS d/ pA jpre Kip )pobed jhe ime tu po bya +f raijed Jorr Bsa Bors, wa poyyr™) eppien, PYSAY 2 PAL wan GY eae pear E>, (SF SES RE feel gt A yo mn via AA CFA s7t Zew Lan 6 Bey Abt OI et Dee fom affy'€ Ferny ZB pa, Coby Py; can ewes ASH Fa Sone 8. Za ee S550 Pe. Leprkiin Neue Lonelor, aM pe ge Ee Ks, he ae i" S00 Ted be ffatet {few cH sie SP Cale jo herity, crue ne werk Darlepes ce C& mies Be oe6 xr) Se yas otye/ CUE of MeL fey K We Paces Aol Fab LAL RYE eof SS Cenfqces Gaer CFanged’ anged? # Der. fo Dewag' EOE Tek ye conn otivekied’ 41° ened KRanschi of jeer” 4 LIS" As Faaoeg. fennese GW PBS (S39 — Ge ca EM LE nee Change 4 are Danse, Sue anef Dee COIEG cag Ay etm of Some, Each fie Hoe ge Cens<e.af Jo ify (FEO ea Lac “Do MEb; ce” 7 pleas hg ts — en serie adr tice Se A —<Enf ee ee Ce 7 fb pecag anprch fa ay Ben pet oe on ial Nee Bat np bof. Eta Lec) ac pm chiteh LO Er WEL Fe om RI ore. 3h An eps a wgen 5 Oe topes kre {ely a , Se tes at Ag A cfm elon Pe, tay ety oy ve" Gag Rikep & co TO eh fee S He “tne feour Fe get oe At, Say acre CGE i Laue bap hoes Sins thon nee she Cason, voit Hi Ze rey i ge Slt Sa geo a “ a RO, , ie fe ght. ety ip FRR ites ofva fe ee wan bot fe ba & PUES Set Teg befe complet eee ‘Se fite A [fe gfek fe eck S Cefn vee/ poe £9 Hnact facatet ph over <q Se |rbahfPesalip foci’ yn r& VE & eee fa [hikes Rept aldose After Sin&, Pte Phy sug fb re nt Sa/Piy, Beam TY Bho we plod Wt Goce SCirin| ptolilg Gh eee pos “pf LS, DS vk Cheated Tia any enr elraw OL T41ees OE Ss , Ne rout” Axi gr fl CL CAG Pee. Onur bos POR CGMS Cty a oo pot 4 ots, 18 aia v. menel “OF er}. 198 LS Setfhigeet Zed hom, i ; : PEE ng ioe: EZ Neve hj ay f oti 7 bn Le Gren MWCO) LRA 7 OD DOE ce bce f are fo tex Kort ffs roof ery a CLA, <% Bele "Lp poiupenet Tae MVR A4uperer a Er aed (lege 9 eevee c7\ ce 1 S71 Cop oe fale Lace fe > ASH, 0B p CGC Cot re Oe ee are [reo af Fes Net Cel S19, eof eee mn £4A J prcee le is Bf appernt wre c k/*e of WAEs MHYE p ALK ‘9, bey f CK ee Refree[ feo” sackar Le, vebe ff Ss ey Crh wets fCeoK WCW London, _ EU (FE2_ cfecheg ST /f LEBh AT En cey JU eler SC PAE Hh koel Ener ctr le otek , “etrangh. FUR 5 Leo = ef ON ed pipe! av fa/ fp lec tiheet PA LaG, 67 Meg Casa $f, Seale of fe Pen Leet ol/ far FU ob fact [on as ana cath. / OC On of My ME CHE CALAIS pe ee ee beg ene a /eb ENS ys (PIE Chane WM Ane hhyte _(e ZBEXK Pefug tf (eet eet Ar RAE SP EES 6 GOf[CEE POM~ Cop bab re eM bag fete Aran see ef Chi 4G oe Plo Gant ee LNG Caen let Perce Aver 7 0 eon Cf SCNen, MO gp Fas

Docket Entries

2020-05-26
Rehearing DENIED.
2020-05-05
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 5/21/2020.
2020-03-02
Petition for Rehearing filed.
2020-02-24
Petition DENIED.
2020-01-16
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 2/21/2020.
2020-01-13
Waiver of right of respondent United States to respond filed.
2019-12-03
Petition for a writ of certiorari and motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis filed. (Response due February 5, 2020)

Attorneys

Daniel Eric Cobble
Daniel E. Cobble — Petitioner
Daniel E. Cobble — Petitioner
United States
Noel J. FranciscoSolicitor General, Respondent
Noel J. FranciscoSolicitor General, Respondent