No. 19-8351

In Re Vinodh Raghubir

Lower Court: N/A
Docketed: 2020-04-24
Status: Dismissed
Type: IFP
Response WaivedIFP
Tags: civil-rights due-process eighth-amendment excessive-fines fourteenth-amendment incorporation
Latest Conference: 2020-05-21
Question Presented (AI Summary)

Whether the Eighth Amendment's prohibition on excessive fines applies to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment's Due Process Clause

Question Presented (OCR Extract)

No question identified. : Los te ee Cwatt Wad Lewd rel Z. or Sua trrodly ener PER fle Ba 1 ar aad Cosltu sion) b: #Péa[ bX 7 ; ty tony Apeomenlr ussodly 72 mM Ant (Ud he PPyakte beilee 6 ep the Albeit. BUCA ¢ Nf Cou Lee urucmeney ove ove ume , NObS Mb Kye i soe none a noe, wos Ibr bxpoer _ Witt & papery coule mdg NOT) 16 2 wen A users yssicml Di U1 B, So anne 4. splee 0 neh ata wae tate ag Mt 1 Wd, ib EMER 6 te — I 070 MYO body best. 5 "Witt & Feo, Cover Chiro , HAV WA Venue ual in lo a itm oo pn oneuse pike bneerd UNF eb in | fie, Alay pir lout ou enusd Vorenlue of Lon DE Fun 45 wae ie Na i i Se a eae i But TAL esTHBUGHED plerice “N65 Nor pan SESE MPING “Me Wy ai obuledriol <b whbperse julicM efton daly tb Ms | eariednl Ove Te ReuEr * Nor inl Dellvelnle Ciuce MP IVME «oer a 4 wrestpse Bortubin A oaveth le amaausy eh yn MEE AO Be m Cele fade “hiked . bit, ene Dey snk ALy To Paes Wr eMnle Th oUo lhe OF <font aie WI oN e alk BE. “ies h a lor a Kane / ios r 7103 , Ag win , hoe P Aumice oF flag Wel , te tains A WwlTe ,4¢ LIMES Coutlees 4 Colle Penwksin inf bars bade HS. LAW ¢ Loot , | NTN Sy conning lates 2 Luge.” ie bors Sse pears ; Pn ae Nee coaleprlpe 1B ie . Neel 1 aU ttoe BF fu MEM PR UEESINES "ou fedeeamd WDB Whe Vion mE Wege Len poeet OU oF peo hyery h fehoe i eee er BG peWted LON HAS onal Motion] "7 Mow) £1AN Hig Pod danke Tle Ses Si dicey ed re aa MEI a, OMe tae SAE BS Ae RN AS Meng. tay Pee ts UN blow | em TRUINE: INIT Merve, [pe elicchead ade: _ st EEIZIN G " ele PEAMNG , AB WITTe, PLE (Bvié oF feeosr wo eee | od dW" Iie “phe Lio 1s 495,04 S vee it 155 He 08 an ofA * A PSEA WISE COLT pein To BEUMeM BASE Plo'se . eer bs ie sat ed Leauge _ lh cclsesoniece sb BRON TP ea MPN OR ERUEAIS ah lig hens oe auberbinhe paket hee eS POP eT Tee EMR EEE, Zo 94S USAC DA EC > Ab airion bead TB LO MING, MBLNGING , MAED INE, ALIELIN 2, EnliAdegnlig , MoMEtinks , FibSpiqVe GEE y Bway: WEEE CRS aaa hog i wa Bit ar. ee aka eee ce te es “| Be hie Gigli FW fe fA Cher h ERIN 1, Wikta Pra The baler pbsclees nage ce ene MB OTD Be Vacs Seen A ZO ie, Hptally Pec SOIL, bone Gide. ae J BONE 7 POEL Pa IAl. OY Mai olhe | BE [ut TAS ~ en | 2UeP AIG THe WEI wi Votirte op Je, talericurtenl genes. Lgg e02, the Peletene of le whir oF ib6ds 00PPS Sibi NT be epee | lets aha] 66S AE Poselivonl OF INVSIN Te use olgery OL My Leow i 8D APR 6 PR Beebe] bodnile eee MENS VfB aS Phe Dole oct if PNGibes pie ENCE re, ul * 1034 v ee foe ov pension “ie oiadpy wie, Hai AM a ope) pete The Se IMRABS ach at ibs ie St Ud TEE Revoun ee ete” aN 54> Vi 222 VO Wem Colby dF 2B ti ee Wk Petal 5 Ae Oe Aden Ce ehe ON | BE ‘ Caer NOE Onl Te oe ATE hse EWE Lore ee ‘OVELTONES eet kailat 0 btowll P3¢SPP © NOE ET eet Site ee rs ae a ee eee Peed on Ely PSUS SCAG bt 97 E> >, AS TB EV EPY DPE GL Ve ANGalL ee | Ope loS Perrin Wwe Reale ued ¢ putida’ qo ike . | = Cite [> POryereoUNle Tie. pyftale HE _LIWUML Peobéd its’ 2. Ak banegeale) bh "MPEEMEMAM Tapeh”, "OO | wre Paleteae OE ole Weare nbors corms Sle NOE De i EN eee wie iol ol pos eee ie SBR ea Pe ieee” Sr i Tir aN P Bee cn PRIETO Cre 8 fil tbe 2 wink Thine paren. dyodriern’y | VR) Te SpleMe. wil; De Bal facing DEBE Si fieuli cq RE SNe dpa Pah htc ion) By 2h Dene hs Sepa fe SUR TNE Tie PRUELE eaGtre Age eletrad Oru by BS ISTE yi 8 MALY. el Td 5 Le Wet Ohler te SuSPeune Poet bre |bibek, | ae he gee Wiegtea BRAC TO alee oy TS BSR ADD. PI 15 Mb MGDOATON OF LéGitadzzonl. bts Gonlct Rusia "nl Cansiudged > Weert | ae. tinal oF boacl reovegdinlos" icons We | Mair, Mier te Poolh bates a , ‘ | 1 Vibiyy Fispere sled LEA WE, ME inl 7s Coleg: Mr yf 7 Mie . Ge Ti EG HEME, Tots aa tee hie eid ied (eA apnened LaPeer pan NL dv FURUA f) Wl. Gd j>8o | ND. DieeaeoN or Patio, fe Tabor . Of, NANCE Tie LE B01 darted Genes ay ne : Pheoy fr 37348 ’

Docket Entries

2020-05-26
The motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis is denied, and the petition for a writ of mandamus and/or prohibition is dismissed. See Rule 39.8.
2020-05-06
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 5/21/2020.
2020-04-30
Waiver of right of respondent United States to respond filed.
2020-02-21
Petition for a writ of mandamus and/or prohibition and motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis filed. (Response due May 26, 2020)

Attorneys

United States
Noel J. FranciscoSolicitor General, Respondent
Noel J. FranciscoSolicitor General, Respondent
Vinodh Raghubir
Vinodh Raghubir — Petitioner
Vinodh Raghubir — Petitioner