No. 20-5208

William Monterial Jones v. Bobby Lumpkin, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division

Lower Court: Fifth Circuit
Docketed: 2020-07-29
Status: Denied
Type: IFP
IFP
Tags: burden-of-proof civil-rights criminal-conviction criminal-procedure due-process evidence identity identity-evidence procedural-default state-prosecution
Key Terms:
DueProcess
Latest Conference: 2020-09-29
Question Presented (AI Summary)

Whether the State sufficiently proved Petitioner's guilt when no contemporaneous identity evidence existed to link Petitioner as the perpetrator?

Question Presented (OCR Extract)

No question identified. : QOSTION(S) PRESENTED ZL. PoRSoantT To THE PRECEDENT ESTARLFSHED Ear UNITED STII N , — TBes NER WHE Fad 904 HMete gol), Ded THE STATE SOFPECTENTLY PRNE Ty's BORDEN OF PROOE OF GUILT To Sostarn) PETETFONeRS » CONNECTION \NHEN NO“ CONTEMPORANEOUS IDENTITY” EVIDENCE EXEST “TO LINK PETITEONGR AS THe PERPETRATOR? Q. CAN A STATE PRoCebURAL RULE ON WHICH THE STATE RELTES ON To ESTARLISH & Proce bural BEFAULT TA THE TASTANT CASE, WE ADEQUATE WIEN APPLIED ARBETRARELN “AND NicoLpTes Due Process 2” F LESt OF “PARTIES ALL Parties do not appear in the Caphton of the cose on the Concer Page. & Vist of all aarkes to Vhe Preceeckag, Cre Garth whore godqmant ‘s AW. Subject of Ahis Poakkon as as Lollowg? 1 Mrak Kaur EUBS ~ Or irginal Presiding Lodge YAO) Front lint se. loostant , TH Troe, 2. Sdan NW. Perevzzi —“etal Ginsel Court pointed) ; Utoo Woedwou \Ste* TAS | tession, Wh T10Sle 8B. Nan Corey Krtorney Por Lhe sike \Qe\ Frankhin Steat GOO, Hosttan, Te 7T00a. Tawre oF AUTHOerTYES CITED CRSES . STATE? EX PRev€ Saenz, dole Teh Ceim App UMis (BL LL tc Hooper i State j aid SW. 3d 9, 1S(Cet. crim App. 07) _ ZF Sones Wi State, 458 Sie 3d GAS Grek. Ceinm ipo, -Heuslon PE Dst| Bors, pet. eff) __ig Rdoersont Ni Strke , (G% Sw. Bd (SCGee-Rep-usttn Pood, get -cePt), —_ — —8 FEbeRAL ¢ “Paplosks> Brauner \ Collins, 13 K 3d ST, VIB" cir wad Brown VW O'Brient, 694 F Supp. 2d Ve HEHICD. Mass. 90o4) Cooper \ Barghvis , No. tob-cy-4a, 2004 US. Dest Leis 17193 2.004 WL SaisloW.-d. Mich. March 3, 2009)—— $$ —— — N a1 Yaa UPKrnis v Baours, Ode & 2d GBl,183 n.aGreir ies) n Nobles y Telnsont )t21 F 3d 409 (Scie 44T)__ _— to, 442 Sneed u Steghans, Aold OS Dest Levis [55678 United Statas WV Bonner, O48 Fad 209 UMeir Bow). 4,5, 1,8, 9 United Stakes \ Bowers | Gil F.3d 41a HisGore)__ een Upiled Seertes W Kittrell, 064 & apd S28 ya4aGhcir aos). __ — 8B ; n United Fetes vv Ksone, | (A FB ra\@re aria) " United Chater y Morales, BH Rad i(eic ac) United Balas NV Timon, 1% © ad Vaan, raaq-si Crete 14g) 8 Vlindhina bons V Weattias 085 F 2d 12H 1255 ee 198i). o_o SUPREME ¢ Desens V Allen) aud Os. 443 i Une kan u rgine Hts OS, 207 (1479) — — rr — 94,10 TRAVEAO N THALER, 133 SHIM GoD. OC ow et STATUES + AB USCS RSHAMI@Y_ LL oY ag use. & asd). _. 4! Fed. Rule. eves. Yot ~ __ ; _— _4g 2 nt) TABLE OF CONTA ORINDNS Beow — — ee es Josshrcten Ce et CONS TEXUTHOAR-L Kil Svarurory, PRoveerons TAME — c v~ Wa STATEMENT OF THE CRSE _ . eee — w= Ss REATONS Fee Gheaaltznh THe Weary oo 2 ti CS CONCLOSFIN _ _ — —_" TAD xo KPPENDIY Gs) RPRENTEK Ki Opinion of Whe Uniked Skotes Tisleick Gael of dppeals for Abe Declheant Bist Houston( RPPELIOFL B? Opinion oF the Unclad States Courts oF Appeals for She” CQrwrert .

Docket Entries

2020-10-05
Petition DENIED.
2020-09-10
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 9/29/2020.
2020-07-29
Petition for a writ of certiorari and motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis filed. (Response due August 28, 2020)

Attorneys

William Jones
William Monterial Jones — Petitioner