No. 20-5735

Michael Dean Perry v. Bobby Lumpkin, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division

Lower Court: Fifth Circuit
Docketed: 2020-09-17
Status: Denied
Type: IFP
Relisted (2)IFP
Tags: antiterrorism-act civil-rights constitutional-rights criminal-procedure due-process federal-courts federal-review habeas-corpus standing state-court-review
Key Terms:
Securities
Latest Conference: 2021-01-15 (distributed 2 times)
Question Presented (AI Summary)

Whether the Suspension Clause of the U.S. Constitution requires federal courts to review the merits of a habeas corpus petition challenging the legality of a criminal conviction, even when the petitioner has already had one full and fair opportunity for judicial review

Question Presented (from Petition)

No question identified. : . Ques Teouk bekimTeD Dd The Tal Habeas low [enousverly, boredo/ Suspaus) Mi Toonu CansTiToloua (elit be Tee GlentWio Habeas Corpus Ad Subpe ' endun, by Hecaud ing exes Moe , Hess, oof Boo glos pages WA Qi. Waits Phabeas lovpus ty lecatious, Sas COAL page Yrsmorandor o€ Lan), (20) Sev 1 ly, vais and of hay Sup Ting Mean ta Tha Eoncelusivel fuove hus Actoul, LicToalped legal Tinoco Liu US Ives lessad whiz oul eldoucovs ly Conceal toa veal Aline, Were Whee hat buadamentel Laut oe) bys dtical 7H Dodger Ord Contrada) Cleadl lon Toll was eae hin coples: See The levi E Crbinsnn ( Pypcale fu billie Offa wor WNC 62,9 20-06, Ne Ove sce | Waudauds voceed sug, os Ale om fo bhyks olbuc ((CA) . pol law ¢ add coval Lops ge tots Copy Yrckwe ba fut 0m td | Mea Goda van Toil nalye a A. 0.) tu WuiTed States Os Te 1 low Telenor, Deny Pel Tianel Yelk vvou) 0 € Ths Code lis.b late bo (s) bom rae: bas Yeleet Goer jad: guewt by Eat lw % agply Tot lal as actor doug To Tox Ove pio tessot Law) OVS WKS 0 a FL Th Plus) witn Tp) Me frees me ie | pr feclon thuises o€ We ur Toentl Py pec) uno E Mer One co (Sifts Louslitolan wd We, Tha due Couce 0 F Lou) pods tous Ol MATL, Stein 14 ol He Conas boustitilon, by wsTed hlen, mgen. Vousk, aed [i bov ously STa Ting That rity aypeedl t= sy Callen bu good Luth hacer The CourThasve vided The (eur) iu Mas Lase ’ quer) doce heveby CERILEY That betlys dppecl 2M Juarod o€ bus [oTion Coy velicl Com udquentis Wl Clim i good uth becuweeiT Wes tul¥ ho pou-Lrvolous1svues. G Couple wrth le AH oe Tse Vee) iT0lf on ay) Le ey SO bn Cov lov alc by vel, W/Urce 15 Deus JEMIES bref Me ps oveds LourplamT on Me Weitz vupublished Lases wr Cul lay bt5 Cases We ITB thdneovs VEAsOn te Chhwe Ceri Afpea. Was Calin. Me gud Gull Lidec) brwolovs Aa yse ol Thgse Uugu blivked bases: Sec Oo onnt*49) Te ol kev tote bolb) ro foon feat, Ela! Claim gy wie alitr , ae [bean demu CeilgElid is TO CL Ain Whack Te 81300 oo) Cor Galen 6 aualey hil jn 25 dauys, bu Tin8 Toad AX tadder, exude ety AtsMoryed $00 plus panes oF Parts babeas loyges aud Widuee ob Ms Acioal, Linh ge Lino tenceLov we 5 end ns bs Ldam ital vA NT% he Val dito E Habeas loys Ad Sc bjicvendyn Cal” 3. Whew The STaft bails te Eile wn dusilev Le habeas Costus whi IS duns b 7a Tote wd Hh habeas lowt tals & 18500 an. (OOL) Ovded Des gua lings Do ves Do be vesaly ed hu po cys, bor aTolil of as Doug 5 mdlov either Covrlu) Thr Witte fhe lwitrE Cima | Ayeals ob Cas wT iw 180 toys hile Lov tun, CxTWstonr oF Thue, Cong ello batctious b bile 6. Wit a€ leaud aus, $ Thos Costdeve) a Callaleval Allaick aw) Sub jecl%G Tce lng pera Lou Sided wey mid al ca, The LL A svucd me Abul Cue ided, bald wey . The Wwoceed a abtyaunct ntl ha STA Elid an apaphae fpes; fous. ¢ avd) aS Ke habeas Low T los ¢ platy fouled ued js cheT ain ¢ . it Vv ¢ Oi) Mee Shaie loiter Ledeml Loot d hr Tian bux LoudaYueatal aed Substaatia l CousTolcoun Mish Grcdies acd We puocess oF Cu) by Cai ban 4 (vovide tien wih a Full, Cav, med) Lie LuidoTeau'y Hed tna wovdw Co Aeveloge fn Cale tu Supa oO lus Aefoal, Caxtonband lezed Fawatence clams, ad alee bell. 0 lus Lae llLelwe Assis Tauce ol Lounse | Claus weal, any) ax his s Oi) he Low 0o€& Aypeal yd La Ostet lows eilowtoiels hay Cetstionie a (LOR) Coitebeeste a Mypoa lability by exceed ng i | i7éd Stage 0€ Hee Cob dpa ly Sis, bo STeac) Go scl) Mev lakhosion only ae Ted esgewlall Decides i LASe Ou. The beené¥, vepea role Cav! Tins, Fay bos Coa/ ue, Exiled t JewonsTiate €xTV4Od ware, Ci tomsTancs dortovsty, The ees Toon C01 The Ostet lon >) Lov To EF Appeals bas bof Wha The Pay ad Shaw bug Case ie Sx Hao Day of Tha Tb 15 acTially tstattad Tides Whathad paste 06) Véasoun Loud) Debefe Ne aloe sad sues Mast Weve’ hac ben mm adpdeeaTion of Pails epanc\e a State LowT om Ha Kent o€ LOA also eeluder yy) ney Ferty-veliet based a Le frente be Lededa( a lr dar Lote, Wash T Aus all etov fad Maelole Ta Qual ol Ke vevle olb)ti)(2), (3-016) bbofia, wes an those oEdeslrielou é Wi ,

Docket Entries

2021-01-19
Rehearing DENIED.
2020-12-30
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 1/15/2021.
2020-12-08
Petition for Rehearing filed.
2020-11-16
Petition DENIED.
2020-10-29
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 11/13/2020.
2020-07-07
Petition for a writ of certiorari and motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis filed. (Response due October 19, 2020)

Attorneys

Michael D. Perry
Michael Dean Perry — Petitioner
Michael Dean Perry — Petitioner