Arthur L. Gurbey v. United States
FifthAmendment
Whether a condition of supervised release impermissibly compels a defendant to answer any questions posed during any examination during the period of supervision, including polygraph testing, or risk violation of his supervised release violates the Fifth Amendment by creating a classic penalty situation in contravention to this Court's holding in Minnesota v. Murphy, 465 U.S. 420 (1984)?
QUESTIONS PRESENTED Whether a condition of supervised release impermissibly compels a defendant to answer any questions posed during any examination during the period of supervision, including polygraph testing, or risk violation of his supervised release violates the Fifth Amendment by creating a classic penalty situation in contravention to this Court’s holding in Minnesota v. Murphy, 465 U.S. 420 (1984)? il