No. 21-894

Helen Gardner v. New York Presbyterian Brooklyn Methodist Hospital, et al.

Lower Court: New York
Docketed: 2021-12-17
Status: Denied
Type: Paid
Tags: 42-usc-1981 access-to-courts certificate-of-merit civil-rights court-access due-process first-amendment section-1981 wrongful-death
Key Terms:
DueProcess FirstAmendment
Latest Conference: 2022-02-18
Question Presented (AI Summary)

Whether the Supreme Court of the State of New York erred in dismissing Petitioner's Wrongful Death Case for lack of a Certificate of Merit

Question Presented (OCR Extract)

QUESTIONS PRESENTED FOR REVIEW. ; 1. Whether the Supreme Court of the State of oO New York, namely, Judge Marsha _ L. ‘Steinhardt, erred and abused its/her discretion by dismissing Petitioner's Wrongful Death Case for want of a Certificate of Merit ; ; which does not apply in New York State. a 2. Whether Petitioner’s First Amendment. right : * to petition, 42 USC §1981 right to sue, give : evidence, to be parties to suits was violated by : . : : the actions of the Supreme Court of the. State ; of New York? : ; : . 3. Whether Petitioner's ~ Fourteenth _ Amendment right of due process, and ‘access ; to the courts was violated by actions of. ; ; Supreme Court of the State of New York? ; ; PARTIES TO PROCEEDING AND RELATED ; ; ; CASES ; : ; Petitioner, Helen Gardner, an individual person, a ; : , "citizen of the United States. : Respondents, New York Presbyterian Brooklyn , . : ; Methodist Hospital, Karina M: Dsouza, M.D., Lien. : : . Khang P. Tran, M.D., Thomas Chen, M.D., Josif. Sholomon, M.D., Alana Sholomon, D.O., Dr. Jordan, ; ET AL. ; ; . , ; e Gardner v. New York Presbyterian Brooklyn , Methodist Hospital, No. 2021-424, State of CC ‘ New. York Court of Appeals. Judgment entered. . ; ; ; September 15, 2021. e Gardner v. New York Presbyterian New York , ; Methodist Hospital, No. 2020-930, State of : New York Court of Appeals. Judgment entered) March 30, 2021. sO ; . . e Gardner v. New York Presbyterian Brooklyn . Methodist Hospital, No. 2019-13202, Supreme / Court of the State of New York Appellate ; . Division: 2nd Judicia!t Department. Judgment . entered October 30, 2020. ' ; e Gardner v. New York Presbyterian Brooklyn. . . Methodist Hospital, ET AL, No. 3010/2017, . , : Supreme Court of the State of New York. ; . Judgment entered July 15, 2019. ; ; . : Il |

Docket Entries

2022-02-22
Petition DENIED.
2022-02-02
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 2/18/2022.
2022-01-18
Brief of respondents New York Presbyterian Hospital, et al. in opposition filed.
2021-12-14

Attorneys

Helen Gardner
Helen Gardner — Petitioner
Helen Gardner — Petitioner
New York Presbyterian Hospital, et al.
Adonaid Casado MedinaVigorito Barker Patterson Nichols & Porter, LLP, Respondent
Adonaid Casado MedinaVigorito Barker Patterson Nichols & Porter, LLP, Respondent