No. 22-1163

Charles Anthony Dread v. Maryland State Police

Lower Court: Fourth Circuit
Docketed: 2023-06-01
Status: Denied
Type: Paid
Response Waived
Tags: administrative-hearing civil-procedure constitutional-rights due-process malicious-intention qualified-immunity racial-discrimination summary-judgment
Key Terms:
DueProcess HabeasCorpus EmploymentDiscrimina ClassAction
Latest Conference: 2023-09-26
Question Presented (AI Summary)

Was the Trial Court's denial of the Petitioner's Motion for Summary Judgment and Request for Hearing without granting the Petitioner a Hearing he requested, legally correct?

Question Presented (from Petition)

QUESTIONS PRESENTED (1) Was the Trial Court’s denial of the Petitioner’s Motion for Summary Judgment and Request for Hearing without granting the Petitioner a Hearing he requested, legally correct when Maryland Rule 2311(f£) requires the Trial Court to hold a Hearing before rendering a decision disposing of a claim or a defense? (2) Petitioner’s evidence raised substantial issues of fact as to whether Petitioner was Fired/Retired because of a Subjective belief, and if so, whether his eventuated from the Racial Disadvantage permitting a White Woman in his Patrol Unit where a Hand Gun was Found while assisting this Person from and to Police Units. See, (Battle v. Mult clland, 429. F.2d 321, C. A. Miss. 19971.) (3) Whether State Respondents knew or reasonably should have known that the Action they took within their shear of Official responsibility when they evicted Petitioner from Public Market would violate Constitutional Rights of Petitioner and whether Respondents took such Action with Malicious Intention to cause a Deprivation of Constitutional Rights or Other Injury to Petitioner are Questions of Fact. See, (Wilder v. Irvin, 423 F. Supp. 639 (N.D. Ga. 1976.) ii LIST OF CASE PROCEEDINGS CASE CAPTION: APPEAL FROM ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING (IAU CASE NO. U-31-00037) COURTIN QUESTION DOCKETNO. DATEJUDGMENT 1) Circuit Court for Baltimore Co; Docket No. 94 Page 295; May 24, 1991 Case No. 91CG2266/ April 25, 1991 2) Circuit Court for Baltimore Co; Docket No. 94 Page 295; July 14, 1994 Dismissal Deferred 3) Court of Special Appeals Docket No. 94 Page 295; Nov. 14, 1994 Notice of Appeal 4) Court of Appeals of Maryland Docket No. 264; Oct. 12, 1995 Petition Denied 5) US. Supreme Court Docket No. 95-7631 Jan. 11, 1996 Petition Filed 6) Circuit Court for Baltimore Co; Docket No. 94 Page 295; July 22, 1996 Respondent’s Motion Denied 7) Circuit Court for Baltimore Co. Case No. 03-C-96-0 04893 April 10, 1997 Summary Judgment Filed 8) Circuit Court for Baltimore Co Case No. 03-C-96004893 July 2nd, 1997 Vacated/Due Process Denied 9) Section 735 ILCS 5/13-218 Revival of Judgement Section 2-1601 20 Year Statute/Filed 10) US. District Court of MD. Memorandum Opinion & May 25, 2018 Civil Action No. PX-18-1177 iii LIST OF CASE PROCEEDINGS Continued 11) US, District Court for MD. GLR 20 CV 0592 March 4th, 2020 Case No. 18-7063 12) U.S. Supreme Court Appeal October 18, 2021 Case No. 21-236/ Denied 13) US. District Court for MD. Order of the Court June 06, 2022 No. GLR-22-01014 14) US. District Court for MD. Order of the Court July 18, 2022 No. GLR-22-01014 15) U.S. Supreme Court Notice of Appeal/Rule 18.1 August 11, 2022 From US. District Court 16) U.S. Court of Appeals (4thCT) Informal Brief October 14, 2022 No. 22-1861 (1:22-CV-01014 GLR) 17) US. Court of Appeals(4thCT) Disclosure Statement October 20, 2022 No. 22-1861 (1:22-CV01014 GLR) 18) U.S. Court of Appeals (4thCT) Order of the Court February 23, 2023 No. 22-1861 (1-22-CV01014-GLR) 19) U.S. Court of Appeals (4th CT) MANDATE March 17, 2023 No. SUMMARY JUDGMENT US. District Court for Maryland 20) Summary Judgment 21) Unlawful Discrimination (Premeditated Malice) iv LIST OF CASE PROCEEDINGS -— Continued RECORD EXTRACT (ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING) 22) Decision and Order of the Superintendent Of the Maryland State Police (Dated Exhibit 1(a) April 25, 1991) 23) Report of the Administrative Hearing Board IAU Case No. U-31-00037 (Exhibit 2(a) April 25, 1991) 24) Maryland State Police April 25, 1991 Notification of Charges (Exhibit 2(b)) 25) Petitioner’s Detailed Report of Personnel Complaint (Exhibit 3(a) April 25, 1991) 26) The Time-Line (Exhibit 3(b) April 25, 1991) 27) Found Property Report by Tpr. Sroka) November 1st, 199188 28) Accident Report No. T-66-18632 (Exhibit 4(a) April 25, 1991) 29) Property Held Record No. P-64615 (Exhibit 4(b) April 25, 1991) 80) Incident Report T-66-18651 (Exhibit 4(c) April 25, 1991) 31) Found Property Report by Tpr. Paolucci Exhibit 4(d)) April 25, 1991 32) Complain

Docket Entries

2023-10-02
Petition DENIED.
2023-06-28
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 9/26/2023.
2023-06-26
Waiver of right of respondent MD State Police to respond filed.
2023-04-06
Petition for a writ of certiorari filed. (Response due July 3, 2023)

Attorneys

Charles A. Dread
Charles A. Dread — Petitioner
Charles A. Dread — Petitioner
MD State Police
Mark Holdsworth BowenOffice of the Attorney General of Maryland, Respondent
Mark Holdsworth BowenOffice of the Attorney General of Maryland, Respondent