No. 23-203

Missouri Department of Corrections v. Jean Finney

Lower Court: Missouri
Docketed: 2023-09-05
Status: Denied
Type: Paid
Amici (3)Relisted (9) Experienced Counsel
Tags: batson-challenge civil-rights equal-protection fourteenth-amendment jury-selection religious-beliefs religious-discrimination structural-error voir-dire
Key Terms:
DueProcess
Latest Conference: 2024-02-16 (distributed 9 times)
Question Presented (AI Summary)

Whether the Fourteenth Amendment prohibits relying on stereotypes about religious views to strike jurors

Question Presented (OCR Extract)

QUESTIONS PRESENTED During voir dire in an suit involving a lesbian plaintiff, plaintiffs attorney asked several questions about whether jurors held “conservative Christian” beliefs. When some said yes, counsel asked the court to strike them for cause, arguing, “I don’t think that you can ever rehabilitate yourself, no matter what you turn around and say after that.” The court disagreed, explicitly finding that the jurors “were very clear in that they could be absolutely fair and impartial” and that they believed “everyone needs to be treated equally.” But the court struck them anyway for their religious beliefs “to err on the side of caution.” On appeal, the court agreed the jurors were struck because of their religious “views,” but held that the strike was not unlawful because it was not based on religious “status.” 1. This Court has interpreted the Fourteenth Amendment to forbid relying on stereotypes about race and sex to strike jurors. Does the Fourteenth Amendment also prohibit relying on stereotypes about religious views to strike jurors, as 5 courts have held, or not, as 5 other courts (including below) have held? 2. Is a Batson-type violation structural, as at least 18 courts have held, or is it subject to harmless-error review, as the court below held? 3. In the context of jury selection, does the Fourteenth Amendment protect both religious status and religious belief, as 4 courts have held; religious status only, as 3 courts have held (including the court below); or neither, as 2 courts have held?

Docket Entries

2024-02-20
Petition DENIED. Statement of Justice Alito respecting the denial of certiorari. (Detached <a href = 'https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/23pdf/23-203_1co6.pdf'>Opinion</a>)
2024-02-09
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 2/16/2024.
2024-01-16
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 1/19/2024.
2024-01-08
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 1/12/2024.
2024-01-02
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 1/5/2024.
2023-12-06
Rescheduled.
2023-12-01
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 12/8/2023.
2023-11-30
Rescheduled.
2023-11-27
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 12/1/2023.
2023-11-16
Rescheduled.
2023-11-13
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 11/17/2023.
2023-11-08
Rescheduled.
2023-11-06
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 11/9/2023.
2023-11-01
Rescheduled.
2023-10-18
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 11/3/2023.
2023-10-17
Reply of petitioner Missouri Department of Corrections filed. (Distributed)
2023-10-05
2023-10-05
Brief amicus curiae of Jewish Coalition for Religious Liberty, et al. filed.
2023-10-05
2023-10-04
2023-08-31
2023-06-26
Application (22A1112) granted by Justice Kavanaugh extending the time to file until September 1, 2023.
2023-06-21
Application (22A1112) to extend the time to file a petition for a writ of certiorari from July 3, 2023 to September 1, 2023, submitted to Justice Kavanaugh.

Attorneys

Alliance Defending Freedom
Christopher Paul SchandevelAlliance Defending Freedom, Amicus
Christopher Paul SchandevelAlliance Defending Freedom, Amicus
Jean Finney
Christina Jeanette NielsenNielsen Law Firm, LLC, Respondent
Christina Jeanette NielsenNielsen Law Firm, LLC, Respondent
Jewish Coalition for Religious Liberty
Howard Nathan SlughJewish Coalition for Religious Liberty, Amicus
Howard Nathan SlughJewish Coalition for Religious Liberty, Amicus
Missouri Department of Corrections
Joshua Michael DivineOffice of the Missouri Attorney General, Petitioner
Joshua Michael DivineOffice of the Missouri Attorney General, Petitioner
The Commonwealth of Virginia and 12 Other States
Andrew Nathan FergusonOffice of the Attorney General, Amicus
Andrew Nathan FergusonOffice of the Attorney General, Amicus