No. 23-5216

Kinley MacDonald v. Michael A. Duddy, et al.

Lower Court: First Circuit
Docketed: 2023-07-26
Status: Denied
Type: IFP
Relisted (2)IFP
Tags: child-abuse constitutional-rights criminal-procedure due-process federal-jurisdiction foster-care hearsay interstate-crime jurisdiction parental-rights standing witness-tampering
Key Terms:
DueProcess Immigration
Latest Conference: 2024-02-16 (distributed 2 times)
Question Presented (AI Summary)

Can a trial court open and remove children in a 'preserve custody' case based solely on hearsay allegations prohibited by state statute in secret and in absence of jurisdiction?

Question Presented (from Petition)

No question identified. : Quel ons Presented “ Belore a Coure ig a pater inveluirge vnabused Children traGicked rato Roster Care. by hearsay , Causing: inne. epairable, hacm, The mother gulered expected Arstress aS Cesult, The OelendantS then used chat distress to retToackively jastrey inidial removal ) refusal to reani ty , and Create an elaborate web of accusatiangS to terminate. a family in absence of ail jurisdiction Cor wUhteh the Federal Courses! abstention SarettonS Sucka departure ot human Preiss eof theo Stele Gourts oF Maine | thet ie Gallgs Lor a ches perare plea ea, Mother +o As Court's @xercise of Superuisery Power. Syert to Resch) his case THESE CAILOREN Seserve your time. “Theale You. n Can a atal Court epen and removes Children in a. “preseve, Custody '' Case based solely on hearsay ateuge~ avons prohibited by Skate. Sratuts wn secret ) and in absence 86 jurisdiction? _ . D) Can a gral Coure threaten ae distressed Mather with Lurler Qeereased Contack with bee children to | Coase. ap * Aaee ment \ Aen wee Pon: TiN. thet agree ~ men’ into an admission pf Quil to Onld @ buse / Tealect= without CuckS of evidence of ehild. abuse | regedr in that apreement or else where? 3.) Con Debend ents reate. Syste nie, barren to effecting AS8iStance of counsel, deny a Family opportunity af Mandered colleguoy, reviews, and appeal an issues of abuse of process ) jurisdiction, Graud wPON he Court, abuse ot Aiscrerion | and wdicial Misconduct +e Conce, & Sermiration of Parental MaMs on a amity deprived oak Candlamenta ly fain opportunity Lo Vig ate, the Locks on Cours record 7 4) Cana state Cours of last resort declare a new Standacd of preview Of evidence against a class of people posh PTSD/ depression so “propenderance of gurdence ” thee ake diagnosis is wand of vase “\eopardy to Children when che Supreme Cour has demanded ap State relrain Com a presumption that a alass of people ace onli Parents (Stanley v. Ellingis 4or US. 6 4S~ @Su-S8 Ci492)) and requires “Clear and Convincinge euidance of abuse /nemlect (Siantosty a Kramer, 4SS USL AGE Dee -9) (\%2)? | S) Can aState Coure of lase Pesort deny «pp cals /atempts , oO a mother's pedresS of tha tral Court abuses then acho these abuses do limit aad inhibit a Family's Tale +o amfeckie §=Aounrseh on Liral apper | ondarint cin aMorrey +o ony beiek what Ske dleams Vewpor tant while also order rae Mother's Counsel (OT to fike ConStriutional /Federal questions on a Niotleris behalf? 6) Co Dri Cy) a. o~ . aes nike “ceakes Disdee® Cour abstain — Wan +he Seat. Cour’ is Cansing itre patra ohe, hatin 40 funda mental Kucera n rahers 2 DM Can a United States Drseeict Coure and | or Une Ved Skates Cours of Appeals objeckively deny Course fo a gedvonar seeKirw. pedresS on @ frattess whieh Peguires BRRE Rene ot Counsel errer 6 €) Con a United States Digance Court and/or Unitecal StekS Coure of Repeal \nve Kel risen Litigation Colsrm Age PeauinmentS of a Peti tone Simply because She iS berry. detained in weil? ie Con a Ornined S cates (since Court and jor Untied SreokS Coure of Appeals require On indi gent Plant r6 poy iM oye Cees under the Prison bitisation Reform cet wkr 8h iS MOT Peru, S am renee aackion o-goingt | he yale. Lise @) Parties “Y ; Kinley MacDonald, Pedisioner } Mather Cfo York County Sail : { bey man Wey Alfred ME 64002 Aim s Miner ehild af Kinley M ae Nonalel Ca "a Minor arid of Kinley MacDonald a a Minor ahd of Rinley MacDonald . Daniel “Seknson, “Lather! of | Sn Gos Prerce Rd Phenix City AL 36e70 Bruce Kile, “ Cather" es a | a“, Papresenteet by: Roger Champagne . ANB Crescent St Prdteleord, ME OYOOS *Sedges" ot York Counry , ME « Michael Duddy , Low Aan Sutton Robert Mel era, “Duda Soka Dee 1 Prddelord (i gtrret Court 28 Adams $+ Biadelord, ME OYOos | Moo strate o& SS Soseph County Pro bet Cound, Suda Seka Qee. 2 , lo0o SS; Mich aan Se Soutk enc 3M yGeo| , * Sadaes'' of SO ‘Dudicta\ Coun, ME . Sadge. Sohn “Soe 3 Sudige Laurence Qos Newbury St, “Rin (34 Portland, ME O4iolYjae

Docket Entries

2024-02-20
Rehearing DENIED.
2024-01-17
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 2/16/2024.
2023-10-24
2023-10-02
Petition DENIED.
2023-09-07
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 9/26/2023.
2023-06-27
Petition for a writ of certiorari and motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis filed. (Response due August 25, 2023)

Attorneys

Kinley MacDonald
Kinley MacDonald — Petitioner
Kinley MacDonald — Petitioner