Did the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals commit Error when that court Denied Petitioner's Certificate of Appealability

QUESTION(S) PRESENTED . A. Did the Fourth Circuit Court of A eals commit Error when That court Denied Petitioner's Cerlificote of Appealability on Grounds that DisPrsitive Procedural Ruling is Debatable And that the Petition. . Had to State a Debatable Claim of the Denial of a Constitutional Right B Od the United States District Court, Western District, Commit Error When That Court Granted Respondent Motion To Dismiss , Denied Petitioner's AAS Petition as Untimely And Barred By The Statute of Limitation , And Concluding hot Petitioner Foiled to Establish That He is Entitled To Equitable Tolling. :