Valentino Bernard Lee v. Ricky D. Dixon, Secretary, Florida Department of Corrections
SocialSecurity Securities
Whether the trial court erred in sentencing the defendant to a mandatory 10-year minimum sentence under Florida Statute § 775.087(2)(a)1 when the defendant did not actually possess a firearm, in violation of clearly established principles of law resulting in a miscarriage of justice
No question identified. : Soe CUE STIONG) FRENED GuksTibs OF BREAT JUTELET The PARTIED STBul Wed THE FAcTuaAs Brass FoR THe dere wel aT len. Ne FATA BAL 1 FH RECORS WREAE1CI ENT PZT LOWER ConTex dl THE CIR GIT CaubrdePahlé”d Fhara TEES Ett 7r2) Re E@ui R mEnW7 OF THE LANA THE MN RAPET NEI OF THEE VidlEWE DEC NUSE THEE WAS 16 SubSTAWTIAL ENUAEAACE U Pon \Nihic.4 A TRIER OF | Fact Could REASONAAIY Conic lodé Thi7T TH ElEMENTS OF THe OF FEMMES HAs hEG.1 PROVEM bE Yond h REASOMALLE dovT. A\iolATIon OF A CIEARIY ExTab lished Phia/Ci Bles OF IAW RESuiliv A mMSCARRIACE OF JusTicé. YuESTioat OF GREAT ISTERE The Thial Cot CLR Ed 11 SENTEn CINE dEkidand Ts AM ad TORY If pm oF Jo YEAR bu THE MiFok mation UMSER THE 10\2o I\\FE STAWE F7TTS. O87TOBLY Fla STATE FOR POSSESSING OF A Fie ear WandGon déadlY wenlon sx THE INFORMATION bECRUSE THE STATE did NET AlLlEAE A FIREARM IAN Conw&eZow WUT AY OF THe CHARGES. aid in PleAdiu@ défendanT did MOT STiPulaTe EiTHER To HS PoSSESS TOA OF AFILEA RI OF 4% THE APPLIC ABLUTY oF § 775. 087(DOW ATHOGH THE S7alE AMELEd A dEGALN \WEAPOM.SANOERCSS WEA Pon “Such Enns did MoT GAGFY AS A FIREARM Fore Pubs OF prihosinl. A MANAATORY MIM MOM SEMENCE tbh EDD 7S 09? (CD(PYO yuder 10-20-~1:FE STATE WESH6n1 OLLREAT iniT CRE | huewe BM EX:Hadcéd MAMAATALY 11 nti O11 SEMEN CE Use THE 16120 1KE STATE TIS 6B CNN), Fla, STAT C05 THETA MusT ANE TH Cbhoond'’s FoR Ed MANCENVRT 111 THE CHak.ti nd documémy, Aud THE JORY MusT make Factual Frvdin§ £EQARIING TH6S BREAD 16 YEAR MppiSATORY 11000194 SEMTEKE UudGes 725. B87 @ BN) ERE FokE. LEQ OI RES Tal THES aT PIE L Aud ACTLANY PoSSES Ed A’ FIREARIM . foFkz : QUEST On @ PREMED I ‘ os TRial Couwlse/§ Fatloté To 1 vlestibaitE pitd rdvucsé DAMEN bei OF THE law tat RElaT on 7b Tle FACTS Caused THE VERS bE n1\iolUN7AEIIY EniTEREA Void AS \W6 lator oF dué PRacess. @) ion oe nna M kicM kd sont 39? US 259. 76h. 96 8. C7 Vi 2 LE. @) iTa FudaAmMnnTal EADoR Fo 1071 Pas THREE VERA Mini jor Da AAA RY SEMTEN CES tot Coun’ Tilo Atid THIEE. 0F THE in Bak wanton becnised cdTétal CaukT Pho PEBIY 1 \lo Ked Fla sTar 725, 0816) whenld bend art ATVORLEY Sh PolaTing Factor! Bass Fok PoSSESSioy OF A FiREA RIN THLE m1 1u m MpNdaTORY \Nould N67 bE AuTHC IZ Ed by law Arid 175 ten Ps t7/ 00 \Noold be Heb al im Pos€d On THE AEFEWABNT 1) A Ton POSSESS) 0 HEME ER MEVER Had AcTual PossESS of THs FiREA Bm. PESSES ton! (8 A SIaTeTohY EIE MENT OF JHE ChImE, (8) THE STATE tA\C0 LLECTIV CHARGE AGFEMAANT \n1i1 TH ARMEA bu hbllaky WHITH AssAudT of bATTERY AS A SINEIG OFEEOE THE CHRECE Consists OF Tins SEPARATE OF Few ses BEG Tauck Flack In J&s Pred FoR Tie Samé oF EEnsé Sin le Ciminsal EP/SESE USCS M STILT Ob A iad E ny ENTE paid 14189 FlokIn COWS: ToTionl, BECRCSE THOSE OFEENSES WERE subsumed WT int THE SEFERIUANTS CONNICTION OF buklaRy WHY Au ASSALIT 84 6ATTER MUTHA FiRERMR mnlgnTiont OF SECTroriS Blo. G2 A Anid Blo. 02 Olb) Hokida ShalvTes C2011) IEE ir £ Sof AATARY PAtrts mor SEHCE SH 5 o we ve mn a ee 5 25. @I@N) SIA STa7 (05) CO lz joleclh (ies | in Tle CHAIN L D Ep ENT 101 must BEE THE Chord 5 FOR Ext HatE00 EAI dtnt@ Keb sc T Arid THE SRY mesr mak Facto el FIST N ie SC MEMS ee Abort Jé YRAR niandalehy mints AO M SEM EWE . Unltd EOF VTS: B87 COW) THRE POLE REF s Plepinil, Arid ACTEANMY POSSESSED AF. REAR