Whether the New York Court of Appeals violated constitutional rights by improperly refusing jurisdiction and dismissing a case involving alleged 13th and 14th Amendment violations

1. Was it legal for the State of New York Court of Appeals to (a) refuse jurisdiction of a case they are obligated by law to take, because it clearly stated important constitutional questions, pursuant to CPLR 5601(b)(1) & (2), constituting a violation of 42 U.S. code § 1983; as well as 13th and 14th Amendment rights, and (b) To do so based on an order of dismissal that itself states no valid or applicable legal grounds for that dismissal? 2. Was it legal for The State of New York Court of Appeals to ignore Substantive Constitutional Violations Including Petitioner ’s 13th And 14th Amendment Rights, Committed By The Appellate Division, First Department That Were Clearly Stated In The Preliminary Appeal Statement submitted October 18, And Jurisdictional Response Filed November 7, 2024? 3. Was it legal for The State of New York Court of Appeals to ignore Substantive Constitutional Violations Including Petitioner ’s 13th And 14th Amendment Rights, Committed By The State Trial Court (NYSC) Which The Appellate Division, First Department Failed to Address That Were Clearly Stated In The Preliminary Appeal Statement submitted October 18, And Jurisdictional Response Filed November 7, 2024? ii THE PARTIES The full name, address, and telephone number of the Respondent parties are as follows: Under Undisclosed Firm Name, A.K.A. Fashion District Dental, Dr. Justin Rashbaum, DMD., Dr. Michael Abrams, DDS. with, Dr. David Stein, DMD, Dr. Jay Rashbaum, DMD, 1410 Broadway, Suite 3004 New York, New York 10018 (212) 391-1385 Dennis M. Rothman LESTER SCHWAB KATZ & DWYER,LLP 100 Wall Street New York, NY 10005 (212) 964-6611 Attorneys for Tortfeasor Justin Rashbaum, D.M.D., Individually and doing business as Fashion District Dental Appeared June 13, 2022, in Substitution For: WILLIAM S SPIEGEL, ESQ.RAWLE & HENDERSON,LLP (646) 386-3339 John P. Anderson, Esq. The Law Offices of Henry Schwartz 32 Court Street, Suite 908 Ill Brooklyn, NY 11201 718 222-3118 Attorneys for Tortfeasors Dr. David Stein, DMD, Dr. Jay Rashbaum, DMD and Dr. Michael Abrams, D.D.S. The full name, address, and telephone number of the Petitioner is as follows: Gina Robinson Pro se, Petitioner 108 West 63rd St No. 22594 Kansas City, MO 64113 (646) 266-1142 Robinson v. Fashion District Dental, et al., No. 153436/2022, N.Y. Supreme Court. Judgment entered Dec. 9, 2022. Robinson v. Fashion District Dental, et al., No. 2022-05698, N.Y. Supreme Court, Appellate Division, First Department. Judgment entered September 26, 2024. Robinson v. Fashion District Dental, et al., No. 2024-00139, State of New York Court of Appeals. Judgment entered December 12, 2024.