No. 24-530

Bethesda University, et al. v. Seungje Cho, et al.

Lower Court: California
Docketed: 2024-11-12
Status: Denied
Type: Paid
Amici (13) Experienced Counsel
Tags: board-membership church-state-separation ecclesiastical-abstention first-amendment religious-institution religious-qualifications
Key Terms:
FirstAmendment JusticiabilityDoctri
Latest Conference: 2025-02-21
Question Presented (AI Summary)

Does the ecclesiastical abstention doctrine bar courts from adjudicating the religious qualifications of the leaders of a religious institution?

Question Presented (OCR Extract)

QUESTION PRESENTED Bethesda University is a Pentecostal institution that requires its Board members to share its religious faith and to act consistently with its Pentecostal beliefs. Consistent with these requirements, Bethesda removed purported Board members who did not share its religious beliefs. Nonetheless, a California state court adjudicated an intra-faith dispute over the Board members’ religious qualifications, allowing a non-Pentecostal religious faction to usurp control of the University. The question presented is: Does the ecclesiastical abstention doctrine bar courts from adjudicating the religious qualifications of the leaders of a religious institution?

Docket Entries

2025-02-24
Petition DENIED.
2025-01-15
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 2/21/2025.
2025-01-13
2025-01-13
Reply of Bethesda University, et al. submitted.
2024-12-30
2024-12-30
Brief of Seungje Cho, et al. in opposition submitted.
2024-12-12
Brief amicus curiae of The Coalition for Jewish Values filed.
2024-12-12
2024-12-12
Brief amici curiae of Association of Christian Schools International, et al. filed.
2024-12-12
2024-12-12
2024-12-12
Brief amici curiae of Wagner Faith and Freedom Center and Heartbeat International, Inc. filed.
2024-12-12
Brief amici curiae of Association of Christian Schools International, American Association of Christian Schools filed.
2024-12-12
2024-12-12
2024-12-12
2024-12-12
2024-12-12
Amicus brief of Foundation for Moral Law submitted.
2024-12-12
Amicus brief of The Coalition for Jewish Values submitted.
2024-12-12
Amicus brief of Council on American-Islamic Relations submitted.
2024-12-05
2024-12-05
2024-12-05
Motion to extend the time to file a response is granted and the time is extended to and including January 13, 2025.
2024-12-03
Motion to extend the time to file a response from December 12, 2024 to January 13, 2025, submitted to The Clerk.
2024-11-07
Petition for a writ of certiorari filed. (Response due December 12, 2024)
2024-09-26
Application (24A292) granted by Justice Kagan extending the time to file until November 7, 2024.
2024-09-23
Application (24A292) to extend the time to file a petition for a writ of certiorari from October 8, 2024 to November 7, 2024, submitted to Justice Kagan.

Attorneys

Association of Christian Schools International, American Association of Christian Schools
Jonathan Daniel BrightbillWinston and Strawn LLP, Amicus
Jonathan Daniel BrightbillWinston and Strawn LLP, Amicus
Bethesda University, et al.
Dominic Emil DrayeGreenberg Traurig, Petitioner
Dominic Emil DrayeGreenberg Traurig, Petitioner
Christian Legal Society
Lori Dawn KepnerChristian Legal Society, Amicus
Lori Dawn KepnerChristian Legal Society, Amicus
Laura Darien NammoCenter for Law & Religious Freedom, Amicus
Laura Darien NammoCenter for Law & Religious Freedom, Amicus
Council on American-Islamic Relations
Jeremy Brooks RosenHorvitz & Levy LLP, Amicus
Jeremy Brooks RosenHorvitz & Levy LLP, Amicus
Foundation for Moral Law
John Allen EidsmoeFoundation for Moral Law, Amicus
John Allen EidsmoeFoundation for Moral Law, Amicus
Manhattan Institute and Jewish Coalition for Religious Liberty
Ilya ShapiroManhattan Institute, Amicus
Ilya ShapiroManhattan Institute, Amicus
National Religious Broadcasters
Michael P. FarrisNational Religious Broadcasters, Amicus
Michael P. FarrisNational Religious Broadcasters, Amicus
RELIGIOUS COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES
Brian Paul Morrissey Jr.Sidley Austin LLP, Amicus
Religious Colleges and Universities
Brian Paul Morrissey Jr.Sidley Austin LLP, Amicus
Religious Leaders
Blaine H. EvansonGibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP, Amicus
Blaine H. EvansonGibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP, Amicus
Seungje Cho, et al.
Donald Manwell FalkSchaerr Jaffe LLP, Respondent
Donald Manwell FalkSchaerr Jaffe LLP, Respondent
The Coalition for Jewish Values
Terry Robert WeissDuane Morris LLP, Amicus
Terry Robert WeissDuane Morris LLP, Amicus
Wagner Faith and Freedom Center and Heartbeat International, Inc.
David Richard DoreyLiff, Walsh & Simmons, Amicus
David Richard DoreyLiff, Walsh & Simmons, Amicus