No. 24-6365

Timothy M. Gemelli v. Perry Nicosia, District Attorney, 34th Judicial District Court, et al.

Lower Court: Fifth Circuit
Docketed: 2025-01-22
Status: Denied
Type: IFP
Relisted (2)IFP
Tags: brady-violation constitutional-tort court-order-disobedience due-process evidence-suppression prosecutorial-misconduct
Key Terms:
CriminalProcedure
Latest Conference: 2025-06-05 (distributed 2 times)
Question Presented (AI Summary)

Whether the 5th Circuit and District Court committed reversible error by not considering the prejudice suffered from the causal link of disobedience by police and prosecutors who suppressed evidence in violation of Brady and other court orders

Question Presented (OCR Extract)

No question identified. : ISSUED Preserve! Pbr PxeyietO filikou3r\ Vie._\OaS. o-C.q.in'fed tf\ LomsiQLAo,. ^.does_(Wtte\\.i_ oJlese OSfady ^ous <e_ erf .cxcti.o o_o^o^o^t.tW VouUicMrvk fcosecufecs._uino_ disohe/ed _\Wee. dou-fV t)ccWs. A"q_. . fe&u __ d _excuWWy_ ey\<Wice \WV Caused fice4uc)tce _ aod_ Vyxoh ._\n cx subsequent' Lolofodo firiL ojnd (Ho^victionZ _loaAc)_'oyer.. 0-0 f\\so, .bjlneo , /'omstihjilofid jo<rt for Compensable Interm due ~ke.9e._<x. dmcL p_cyiui S uPire.ss10afaij5.m9 Least of h^mside. Personal PfoPtf fv ?an .X-J)icLtW-JVsj?ict tourX and tW StVx CjfcuAr \qoY\ _Cc> novrwA error W no"V aosbsp.o_tW_xo,a\.a _ t o.na&W _ fbuesid 0.0 _vtf\_PeA\A> ooecs J&xj efL _vs_iW_J^uoA<dtv Abr iWis Pap^/TI s office r £jx(\<>P(k #-iA(J the other /fePoad eois_(ft/LCo^J o^3 iJair ci^ao <°\/tde^ce tn rK dei^claAt as Ordered Lv tile tnol Louft_ 7ud.9£' r>r rlo ~f/?dv has/e the descretortarv OuMiorLy to JoJ3)i5.O0£.*LA^ they Lade fr ~t~V\e_Prejudice _cuoci daftn that " iiitS Petit one, f_ftouJ SuftefS tro^\_tAf\eXbCsc e 0A0 W__ Aonss9buencei _of their actions of e\/ick\Ace GuPPf^s \oj\^ of Very specific to^rt Ot&zSzA 'evdAeacg-.ar e 7T. J)jJ _ifcc._5hb. Aircu/t .efxofdoy . a\qY> v ,0d ate,rifV\^c^\0!if\_ o'fr_,Os.\\_£V^ d^OC£__C,Q(\teM A^d. _uf\„ . ftivYionsxs __Pell YKofuis ioAV outY r.oc\s\Aecv^ YW „ Pe*hYioo.t^s_nee d of" vV ~fc>\f ~VW_ LoWado Y'f.vcA _ -fe.cforung ~Vo ~\W \deaVvc.a\ oAWaed V>cVi^\^lOvWssi-3 .(XX JAe ..UamjsuXxTv.^ Yrv,<x\ _\AvoV\v .cVlJtN^_^<^S YoO^d _ noY (juiHy?fege ftfPX^Pi^ ?5s_33 ___ _ _ -. . JTL > 3)id tke/Tfb hrcurt err in their_ .-find//# ibocLlanefA, MtQS/A^lxJo^A _ eo_t h^y^oouJioQlxj.Ui lltulll j _ $eliberal . touf{s _ drc/efs jb 3i\Lfi _ Petit]one S' Hit t<t\! P/tortes _and . CowcUtt lotalmts .as ___ .Ordefed_bv^fht 'trial l.oarl~ ^dseXSggBwYSjkS "P\/~. Xxd Ylne Y)\gA~ CooorV cK(\d_^V\e .e.cr.aC^cxa^TAkS Jo;>iJ&idifv9j!\ .IWe£<x ___ .S.iAsk sYxod cdo A 2vok o.0_oil_^ jb.'l SYode.^eioY_r\od^ _uP Y>V fY-AanePcx of Ahe_\ 0aP_9.ro P.D.oi^'/ ±o.ucked_^ _ __(X 5\$\sW oA\g.S(A\cm suww /e ft-o\)A)\e CAaSf. dbvT__ IP) year old acajS(X hoi/\_^Av^jpof cAd aYq said bpr ~fk\Wr mn\ ested. \\tT) \py \derv\vf\coAXo-va. o.ftkj. .U3laeaAHae_^o^^C )BC^^d_j Hknkc "dnp kVp^dhoAS YxaPPeaedX^&e BAQMseoft^_ ,l)pe.s_ < A _ IV\€_ f\es Povj'xA Lcx^N^CX^^ xcosx Os^XO ooT^ cmv^ _ VAo/o^^S-... l CirtioAeA VVie. (LAoCcxAo _ls-o<\3VM>s\C fvA CXttA AWsAvWb . AW <x\\^3eA _\/.\ _\o.Bo fT\ e ^seco/A . S.fe\ +o S.o durA doatevcV JV\eC_ vov\\x VieX — FLlse 9\oi~ —A^fi FAiWr_fbr C.utW\2i _ her ” .oui\cl_ Jf}ec_ JO^oAfser 6?f~ fiAoorvc \oA\y _ Jb.Y_iiyS!__oo&>A _ ecnoA Av-xst five Aqn,£ \pefbce o<\ ^cAa. 1q-^2£>V~1 ._V_. , .Ca^epcx _bt^V\___,_ _ Louis ioacl . . ay\A._^oUxoAo_fo jno^x _jrW_toVocoAo_ o'ffi.ce\C_ fkil fo_W. “f I OVOfU -A O v3 \f\ ioSXiJJL ___ :Qis j^zQoo coAi A.) jr^Ns\<LQAi _iokiAn__Ce.sufeA __v^ _o^. aqL feraiW^ •_ VerAicfr (See.ftp_?x: _P__)_ Rt^/ersabU Error bv nof~ _do_ns'\d&cjM.idle Pr^judic*Pzhhoinzr ^Suffered -fro^\ fhe. tauxunJ Link <nf_ ^ausodrion^ hv not Considering fini harm caused bv the _disqbtdienct —o f.Jhh'A< aad_Pros?cuiofs to In^ph jjji hk toufi DrStr^ doijjhj^ck Jkei^ ( 5'uPKtsszS _ Ejs/idtflCPj (n\/inlnrhnn ofa\nd%lslio'

Docket Entries

2025-06-06
Rehearing DENIED.
2025-05-20
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 6/5/2025.
2025-04-16
Petition for Rehearing filed.
2025-03-24
Petition DENIED.
2025-03-06
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 3/21/2025.
2025-01-16
Petition for a writ of certiorari and motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis filed. (Response due February 21, 2025)
2024-11-08
Application (24A465) granted by Justice Alito extending the time to file until January 18, 2025.
2024-11-05
Application (24A465) to extend the time to file a petition for a writ of certiorari from December 4, 2024 to January 18, 2025, submitted to Justice Alito.

Attorneys

Timothy M. Gemelli
Timothy M. Gemelli — Petitioner
Timothy M. Gemelli — Petitioner