Dennis Sheldon Brewer v. John Ratcliffe, Director, Central Intelligence Agency
AdministrativeLaw SocialSecurity JusticiabilityDoctri
Whether the Fifth Circuit improperly disregarded established standing principles by dismissing a pleading sua sponte contrary to Supreme Court precedent
1. Shall this Court permit the courts of the fifth circuit to openly defy both this Court ’s mandates and statutes to establish their own circuit specific precedents which effectively override this Court and Congress for: a. Standing? The well-established principle of standing is afforded to all who have (i) injury in fact, (ii) can establish causation, and (iii) a statutory means of redress exists, as defined in FDA v. Hippocratic (2024) issued June 28,2024, as the fifth circuit was engaged in Medicine 602 US concurrent, overlapping, and openly defiant actions, wherein a fifth circuit district court disregarded those well-established bedrock principles of standing to dismiss sua sponte on June 6, 2024, one day after docketing, the petitioner ’s pleading (described at paragraph 11A below,