James Randall Moehle v. Florida
Whether this Court should revaluate its decision in Williams v. Florida and hold that twelve-person juries are constitutionally mandated in criminal felony cases
No question identified. : i A. QUESTION PR ESENTED FOR REVIEW Whether this Court should reeval uate its decision in Williams v. Florida , 399 U.S. 78 (1970), and hold that twelve-person juries are consti tutionally mandated in criminal felony cases – or at least in cases that involve a potential puni shment of life impri sonment. ii B. PAR TIES INVOLVED AND RELATED CASES 1. Parties In volved The parties involved are identi fied in the style of the case. 2. R elated Cases a. State of Florida v. James Randall Moehle , case no. 2021-CF4832, Florida First Judicial Circuit Court, Escambi a County. Judgment entered on April 20, 2023. b. James Randall Moehle v. State of Florida , case no. 1D2023-1112, Florida First District Court of Appeal . Opinion entered on February 3, 2025, reheari ng deni ed on March 12, 2025. iii C.