Whether a person seeking return of illegally-seized property under Fed. R. Crim. P. Rule 41(g) has an absolute right to reject the government's offer to return the property where the government continues to deny liability or constitutional violation

No question identified. : | Que STIow _ PRESEWTED | | This petitisn presents Phe Following gueshen ; + | W he Her a fcson Seeking, return of Mega lly ~ Seired propetty i | under fed. R Crim, P Rule 4G) has an absolute fight fo | feject the Goverameté offer fo ceturm the prepetty where the | Government Continues fo deny liability of Constitutions | vielabtoar’ _ | | | ii | TABLE OF CowTEentTs | Question peesevieD TAGLE OF AUTHORTTSES ||. ee i OPINIoW Below... ... .. 1. ee ee eee Juarsoretiowm . ee ee ee [Relevavy Rules. STatemen T of TH CASE... 1... 3 | REASOws FoR Ghawtivg THe WATT)... |) CY TL. The decision belaw iyrets_basic contact tow : principles ond this Court's fectyian in Compra Ewald be | A, Posk-teiah Rade WG) mehiens matt be thehd os Civil _complamts Seeking egnibable felch 4 | B. Bose, hed an absalebe tight Fs reyech the Gavetnmets | offer yo eetarm bis propelty in favel of prising his claims for relieh oo. owe ee eee ee G Cc, Vader Campbell -Ewals tha Aistrich court caull net | force Basey te aces} the Governmays offer by | OAc Fing him ds provide Contack information fo where fe tet the pryethy. 8 | . ’ Vhe decision below conflicts with this Court's —@ Comets { —EE rr i [A peendx A: Court of Appects Memeorandum Opmten. . (Tuy ay mar) ade 1A gewndix BS Dissrrey Cows's Order lA pondx C1 Basy's Role WG) Motion | (May 32M) A pendix D; Governments WVeaOppet ton . ' | . (Tuy do oa) oo | | Appl E Verified Wotice of Resedron of Goy's SeHlemnd Offer ( Sopp. 3 deal). 35% 3b. S| ne ra or er a ee . . .o . . ) | | | a es _@— SSS | a ke ee (airing Meiery. Keir Jah Fad S48 S554 (4h Cy 1475), a n/a —— ee ee ee Here, Suere 1S A® indicaften ‘The dishrichk courh and Mah | | | Cirenid tfrated Basey's mean like «a cyl Complaint, Fiesy, neither i | courh consjderaJ any tauibabhe fockols , Second | instead of Peguiting | Tre Government fo File ia Cespan sive pleading — which uuld be | tne notmal Shing defendants do When facing a avi Complaint — Me | courys candoned The Government's Filing. of a ‘Mon Qopssition, “ | | ' C beh, Ap 4 %O.33a), pad Paid, She Government wes allows te Aen, | Frade sks} ° Base 's chtas whyle asgecdi ths ow, Counterclaim based re tn ey Sten 8 EI Sen Sonne Oe on «a lack, of ned for Bosey'S prapely. @ | Had the courts treated Basey ' Rule YN) mabion Jike a complaint | trey, vawuld have Cealized Thay BaSty wos “the master oF his claim. “ Mien Phuoa vy, Racontruss Co, 55S Fig SOF 577 (4am Ci, dol) Busey a EN ft (etnias a ee err wy Per Governmen’ was Tha oaly ene wih any Say as to what : legal theerjies he could assery, See Ap, Caterpittar Inc. v, I OWA Sam e 42 US, 286, 39a FAL 7 (1982), Thas Kua courts Should | ay NE have Ais teyarded the Governmant's attempt 4s inject a lackeF = continuing need theory into fr. case fe defeod a Aetetmingtion of JinbiNity on | Basey's clatms, Perhaps mare impcthanyty hand tre courts beated Basey's emabion | @ 1 View a complainy they would nevel hava a owed Wwe Seniors) feo de [ati At cammon haw, ence a lausutk wos filed any wouldbe | I I defendant whe tried te den, Vreloitt by could ack eee “a Fender, | . 6 @ | Campirelt = Ewald, 577 V5, af 17° (Thomas 5, Can carting), But here, the courts ; | below were nen plussed b Basey’s ebactrons te ta Government's | offer despite ne admismien of fedidity, | There 1S unfeCtancdt® dicta in the Winh Gresit's flat} fon | deciesen ran fend defow relied on Pret Bays when the prpsdy, m | qusstien if ane Leager nasdad For evidentiaty purgeSef so. Th lesals ty | of he Search and Srizare irs ao boager on ‘SSue,... Fo4q Fd at 1309, | Zs ta,4 Cally trae, Prowl! Does a man's cin} te bald the | | Governmat accountable For ibs Fourth Amend mut wsony f Cie ond Rll wih the Seve tiga'’s whims of wher (+ will use plepsDy as evidence? | Te the. wictio of an Mesel SUUEL tre Ie aility of i} mey femain T | oO Very bi5 WSS Ue, The on moengt fo one's diyarhy From an ilbesad Search ney dwell Fo¢ Yes as he ysems for Some Semblance of | justice. Fndred as Saltinyon