Whether a consumer claiming harm from personal information disclosure must plead public revelation to establish Article III standing, or if disclosure to any third party without consent is sufficient; whether the VPPA bars business disclosure of information about non-subscribers of audiovisual goods or services

are: 1. Whether a consumer claiming that he was harmed by disclosure of his personal information must plead that his information was revealed to the public to establish Article III standing, as the Third, Seventh, Tenth, and Eleventh Circuits have held, or whethe r the consumer need only plead that his information was disclosed to any third party without his consent, as the Second Circuit held below. 2. Whether the VPPA bars a business from disclosing information about consumers who do not subscribe to its audiovisual goods or services.